This is an old revision of the document!
* Danilo Muniz
Group 5
Reproductive interference between competing species
Introduction
Reproductive interference may be defined as any kind of sexual interaction between individuals from different species that reduces the fitness of at least one of them. Even though it is relatively common, reproductive interference is usually ignored as an ecological process than can influence species coexistence and exclusion.
Fig. 1. Reproductive interference may take many forms. Figure stolen from this place.
Reproductive interference can occur for many reasons, one of which is failure to discriminate conspecifics from heterospecifics. This sort of failure is more common among closely related species, which also commonly compete for resources. Such is the case with the ladybug sister species Harmonia yedoensis and Harmonia axyridis. These species compete for and also interfere reproductively with each other. The interference is asymmetrical, so that H. yedoensis suffers more fitness loss from it than its sister species. In addition, H axyridis grows faster, and is more effective at hunting most aphid species. H. yedoensis, however, is specialized in a highly elusive pine tree aphid species.
It has been hypothesized that H. yedoensis is not competitively excluded by its sister species exactly because it is specialized in a “difficult” prey, and also because individuals can find refuge in the pine trees. More information can be found in Noriyuki et al. 2012 (link available below).
Assignment
Given this amazing information about this incredible pair of species, develop a mathematical model that reproduces the main characteristics of the interaction between H. yedonensis and H. axyridis: competition for prey, reproductive interference, prey specialization by one of the species.
Questions and suggestions
Can you show mathematically the importance of having a refuge (the pine trees) for the persistence of H. yedonensis populations? (Notice that the model need not be spatially explicit).
In their discussion, Noriyuki et al. suggest that the direction of reproductive interference can determine the evolution of ecological specialization. Does this suggestion make sense?